Guybrush had to bite his tongue to stop himself from repeating that he thought Elaine looked like she'd lost a few pounds (his tuckle-bear would probably be more bear than tuckle if he mentioned it again); however, he found himself dumbfounded and rendered completely speechless only a few seconds later. His face went through a world of emotions in those seconds, reflecting denial, confusion, acceptance, then a second helping of confusion: "Whoa, uh. Ah, huh?"

He rubbed the back of his neck uncomfortably. Did she have amnesia? Or was this another product of time-travel Voodoo gobbledegook? Or some other side effect of his being dead, if he'd died at all? Or had LeChuck done something to her after all? With the whirlwind of theories about this place going on in his head, the only thing he could manage was, "But- but that was years ago! You don't remember our years of matrimonial piracy?"